Why the carl Lentz Book seems to Hurt So Many People
T30 Team
4 min read·Awareness

Read the comments under any post about the Carl and Laura Lentz book and you'll see a lot of anger. Under the anger, most of it is hurt.
Carl led a large church. When a leader like that falls, the people who trusted him don't just watch it happen. They feel it. Not only that, but it seems to permeate through the entire cultural ecosystem. And when a book about the fall shows up, it can open the wound all over again.
What's really going on in those comments
Three things keep coming up, and each one is worth taking seriously.
First, it's a double betrayal. When a pastor has an affair, it breaks his marriage, and it also breaks something with everyone who trusted him with their faith, their marriages and their stories. It's almost like an Anikan Skywalker scenario. He was supposed to be the best of us, the chosen one who had it all together and was showing us the real way to follow Jesus. He was helping celebrities discover faith. He was pointing people to the cross. He was someone who had it all, and yet still did the things he did. People who never met him can feel lied to. For many, that is real grief. And for most, considering anger is a secondary emotion, what most likely sits underneath that is fear. Fear that if it can happen to him, then what hope does my husband have? Fear that "Hey look at Laura Lentz! If he cheated on her what shot do I have?" Statistics say that over 70% of men struggle with sexual integrity related issues. I doubt every single comment online is from the remaining 30%, which means there is a lot of shame, fear and deflection happening based on what is going on in their own lives, and that makes sense.
**Second, it feels too soon, although time is subjective.** He left the church in 2020, and the book is out now. To a lot of people that doesn't feel like enough time to have healed, let alone to teach others how. We'd be careful with that one. Nobody outside the marriage can say how long the work should take, and the Lentzes say they took it one day at a time. But we get why it looks quick to people who are still hurting, especially those who perhaps are in the same boat.
Third, it looks like a money grab. Critics say he is profiting from his failure. Whatever his motives are, and we can't know them, a book is a product with a price. That bothers people, especially when the story it's built on cost others so much. But to keep it in perspective, many of today's counselors who excel and have thriving (and profitable) practices and programs around sexual betrayal have this as a part of their personal story.
Why a book can't settle the question
A book can say all the right things. It can say "I take responsibility" and "I did the work." Words are the cheapest part of rebuilding trust, and people who've been burned know it because words were the easiest part in the lying, the manipulation and the second life.
If you're the person who broke trust, here's the hard part: you don't get to decide when the people you hurt are ready to believe you. And if you're the person whose trust was broken, you don't owe anyone a quick forgiveness, whether that's a spouse or a stranger on the internet.
The thing that actually moves a hurt person is this equation: time + consistency. Not one good month, not a public statement, not a book. The same honest behavior, again and again and again and again and again when nobody's clapping and it costs something to keep doing it. That's the marker that matters, and it's what we'd say to anyone in recovery, including the Lentzes.
What to do with your own reaction
- Name what you feel. Anger, grief, doubt and even a little hope can all be there at once. None of them make you wrong, and none of them make you right. While you cannot name their feelings, you can yours. And you can do the work to understand why they are there and what information they are giving you (because feelings are data!)
- Separate your story from theirs. A headline can pull up your own betrayal, or the one that is sitting underneath the surface that maybe you and your family are ignoring. If it does, that belongs with your therapist, not the comments.
- Hold your judgment loosely. You can be skeptical and still wish a couple well. You don't have to pick. Also it's the comment section on the internet, so we suggest just stay off of it altogether for your own mental health.
- Measure your own life by consistency. Whether you broke trust or had yours broken, the question is the same: what does the next singular day look like? And then the day after that?
Where T30 fits
Consistency is hard to show and easy to say, and that's what T30 is built for. The Lentz family will have to realize that if they haven't already, and so do we. T30 isn't therapy. Ascension by T30 gives the person rebuilding trust a place to check in every day, so follow-through is something you can point to. Anchored by T30 gives the person whose trust was broken private tools to sort through what they feel, at their own pace.
If you're in crisis or feel unsafe, please reach out to a licensed therapist or a trusted local resource. This article is educational and isn't a substitute for professional support.
Sources: Faithwire; ChurchLeaders; Protestia (critics' view)
T30, the recovery hub of hope.