Carl and Laura Lentz's New Infidelity Book: Can people Separate the Message from the Messenger?
T30 Team
4 min read·Insights

Carl and Laura Lentz have a new book out on infidelity, and the comments section is exactly what you'd expect.
Some people are glad it exists. Others think he has no business writing it. If you've been through betrayal, you may feel both at once. We're not here to review the book or to rule on the Lentzes. We want to talk about the question underneath: can you separate the message from the person who wrote it, is it even possible, and/or why would you even want to?
What the book is, and why it's divisive
The book is Overcoming Infidelity: 10 Conversations to Help Heal the Hurt, by Carl and Laura Lentz. It came out October 20th and is built around ten conversations couples can face after an affair. Carl was the lead pastor of Hillsong's New York church until 2020, when he left after his affair became public. The two stayed married, and they say they wrote the book to help people who are where they once were. Whether or not that is true is apart of the cultural drama surrounding the release.
The pushback is mostly about him, and rightfully so. Critics say he hasn't shown real repentance, that a book turns his failure into income, and that someone with his record shouldn't be handing out marriage advice. Supporters point out that people are asking for help and that the two of them have lived the thing they're writing about.
We haven't gone through the book here, so none of this is a verdict on what's inside. But we've heard the argument enough to write some about what we think here.
Art and artist: where the split works, and where it doesn't
With a song or a movie, you can often enjoy the work and set the person aside. The work doesn't ask you to trust the author because it's passive, entertaining and frankly not that personal.
A book about rebuilding trust after betrayal is different. Its main claim is that a person can change and that trust can be earned back. So the author's own follow-through isn't a side issue in this case and it's probably pretty evident that the Lentz know this. The cost is high to listen to a specific voice because what goes into the mind, is what becomes the foundation for decisions. Our position is you can take a true sentence from anyone, including someone you don't respect, but you can't hand your marriage over to anyone's advice just because it's well written. There needs to be some discernment, there.
Nobody outside a marriage can see what's happening inside it, and we can't see into anyone's heart. What we can say is that trust gets rebuilt through what a person does over time, consistently and that's true for every couple, including this one so ultimately time will tell if the words in the book hold true.
How to read any recovery book, this one included
- Judge the idea first. Is it specific, and does it fit what your therapist or your own experience already tells you? Skip anything that sounds like a promise because we know about broken promises with regard to betrayal.
- Ask what the author gains. A book can be useful and still be a business. Both can be true.
- Don't let it set your timeline. No book can tell you when it's time to forgive, stay or leave. That call belongs to you, ideally with a therapist who works with sexual betrayal and is a part of your story.
- Watch the follow-through, not the story. This applies to authors and to the person in your own home. Words are a start. Consistent, checkable action is what builds trust.
Where T30 fits
A book can give you words, but trust gets built in the day-to-day. T30 isn't therapy and it isn't a book club. Ascension by T30 gives the person rebuilding trust a place to check in every day, and Anchored by T30 gives the person whose trust was broken private tools to process on their own terms.
If you're in crisis or feel unsafe, please reach out to a licensed therapist or a trusted local resource. This article is educational and isn't a substitute for professional support.
Sources: ChurchLeaders; Faithwire; The Christian Post; Protestia (critics' view)
T30, the recovery hub of hope.